Quirky Query Hub playbook · 2 minute read
A round to try
You always know the exact number of imaginary stairs in a fictional building.
An apparently useless power can inspire a story role. Ask what tiny community would consider its owner indispensable.
Put it into practice
Imaginary-stair knowledge offers almost no ordinary practical value, but could matter to a fictional architect. Let players propose a niche before scoring usefulness. A low score should reflect the announced situation rather than the first listener’s inability to imagine one.
Keep uselessness specific enough to explore
Absolute uselessness can end the conversation before it begins. A power that does nothing gives players very little to work with, while a power that finds the exact center of a blanket creates a tiny question about when precision might matter. Add a harmless limitation, such as needing an empty mug nearby, and the group can imagine an unnecessarily elaborate picnic inspection. The comedy comes from the mismatch between preparation and benefit.
Try a round where each person receives a different weak ability and has to propose a fictional service using it. Someone who can identify an imaginary cloud's nickname might open a sky souvenir stall. Someone who can make bookmarks bow might run a miniature library ceremony. Keep the proposal within the card's actual rules. Do not quietly turn a narrow ability into universal mind reading, time control, or limitless invention. After the pitches, let players vote on most charming business and least practical opening hours as separate categories announced beforehand. The distinction allows a power to remain useless in ordinary life while producing an entertaining character. Close by asking what the character enjoys about their odd talent. That gives the round a warmer ending than repeatedly arguing that an imagined person has no value because their ability is inefficient.
A few good questions
Must usefulness have one universal rating?
No. State the situation first. An ability may be valuable to a fictional specialist and nearly irrelevant in ordinary life.