Quirky Query Hub playbook · 2 minute read
Separate a tied distance from a tournament rule
The tool compares each submitted ranking with the reference ordering using positional distance. Equal distance means equal disagreement with that reference, not identical lists. Keep the tie if the group values discussion over a single winner.
A runoff, nearest-pair bonus or audience preference is an optional manual tiebreak. Announce it before play and keep its score on paper. Do not imply that the browser has a hidden tiebreak selector.
A concrete turn and its outcome
Two players can both have distance four from a reference ranking while disagreeing on which items moved. Ask each to explain one position before declaring a shared result. If the host previously announced a paper runoff, conduct it; if not, introducing a new rule after seeing the tie would favor whichever explanation the host already likes.
Work through an equal-distance result
Use A-B-C-D-E as the reference. Alex submits B-A-C-E-D: A and B each move one place, D and E each move one, and C stays, making distance four. Blair submits A-C-B-E-D: B and C each move one, D and E each move one, and A stays, also making four.
The two orders are different even though their totals match. Let Alex explain the A/B swap and Blair explain the B/C swap. A shared result is now understandable. A paper runoff can ask both to rank a new set under one announced criterion; it should not quietly weight whichever item the host preferred after seeing these totals.
A few good questions
Does equal ranking distance mean identical lists?
No. Different arrangements can have equal distance from the reference. Keep the tie or apply a previously announced manual tiebreak.