Quirky Query Hub playbook · 2 minute read
A round to try
Vote for the clearest case, most inventive example, or strongest response.
Choose one criterion before the speeches. Audience voting measures this group’s reaction, not an objective truth.
Put it into practice
If the criterion is clearest case, listeners should hear the same voting question after both speeches. Do not add funniest voice as an unannounced factor. Show the actual result and allow a tied round rather than claiming an authoritative verdict.
Evaluate the case without evaluating the person
Choose one main criterion for the audience. Clearest argument, most imaginative example, or best response to the opposing case can each work, but they reward different things. Tell speakers which one you selected before they prepare. Avoid a vague instruction to vote for the best debater, which can sound like a judgment about personality or confidence rather than a choice about a short fictional performance.
Suppose one speaker supports giving umbrellas honorary citizenship and another opposes it. The audience can ask whether each side explained a benefit or drawback that follows from the shared imaginary rules. A funny line that ignores the actual proposition may be entertaining without being the strongest case under the announced criterion. Let voters decide privately if that reduces pressure, and collect the agreed number of votes only once. When announcing the result, say which side won this round rather than who is smarter or more persuasive in general. Do not require the losing speaker to agree with the audience. Offer both a chance to name one line they enjoyed from the other side, with passing allowed. This makes the ending about listening as well as winning. If a judge cannot choose, a tie is a legitimate result and often a better finish than manufacturing a decisive criticism.
A few good questions
Can the audience change judging criteria after speeches?
No. Announce the criterion first and ask the same voting question afterward, using only the actual ballots cast.