How to Judge the Best Bad Advice

Compare two complete three-step pencil-jar plans under one announced host criterion. Sample integer ratings show how administrative effort can be judged and explained, while keeping the human evaluation distinct from Wrong Answers Only's anonymous voting format.

Editorial credit: — Quirky Query Hub editorial pen name · Editorial & testing methods

Original illustration for How to Judge the Best Bad Advice

Quirky Query Hub playbook · 2 minute read

Review safety before judging creativity

Read the whole three-step plan before entering a score. The local checks confirm basic completeness, required words and simple scene vocabulary, and screen some unsafe terms. They do not understand every instruction or guarantee harmlessness. Reject or replace a harmful plan even if it passed the checks. No shock-value bonus can make an unsuitable submission eligible.

Announce one human scoring rubric

Bad Advice Battle uses a host score from zero through ten, entered as a whole number. One workable paper rubric gives up to three for connecting all steps to the situation, up to three for a clear escalation and up to four for using the constraint creatively. Explain that rubric before writing; the tool does not automatically calculate those sub-scores or decide what is funny.

Use the same criterion for every player. A seven reflects this host's judgment in this round, not a scientific creativity score. An omitted score must be completed deliberately, and two equally strong plans can receive the same total. Do not manufacture a public vote to settle a host-scored round.

Compare two complete plans

Imagine the selected situation is a lonely pencil jar. Alex writes a parade for the arriving pencils, an unnecessary printed route map and an explanation that the jar has applied for city status. Blair writes a welcome desk, a formal exchange program with another fictional desk and a closing report from the stationery ambassador. Each writer must also integrate the actual generated constraint before submission.

Under the administrative-effort criterion, a host could give Alex seven and Blair eight, explaining one visible feature of each plan. Another host could reasonably prefer the parade. Record each score once, move to the next player and invite a brief discussion afterward. The result is a human evaluation of the submitted plans; it is separate from Wrong Answers Only's anonymous election.

A few good questions

Does the tool vote for the best advice automatically?

No. A human host scores the accepted three-step plan. Local word checks are limited eligibility screens, not humor or safety certification.

Plan your session

Take it to the game

Play now ↗

More original ideas · Game night guides

Find your next good question

Your games, your device

Players, answers, favorites, and history stay in this browser. Export a backup before clearing browser storage.

Select a backup to preview its record count.

Recovery copies

Restore and clear operations keep a pre-change copy in this browser. Download one before restoring it.