How to Rate an Unusual Superpower

Rate a power for a stated fictional task before comparing its usefulness with its absurdity. The biscuit-detection example shows why two players can reasonably give different numbers to the same ability. Use their explanations to discuss the setting and keep the two judgments separate, rather than combining them into an unexplained overall verdict.

Editorial credit: — Quirky Query Hub editorial pen name · Editorial & testing methods

Original illustration for How to Rate an Unusual Superpower

Quirky Query Hub playbook · 2 minute read

A round to try

Rate usefulness for finding a lost pencil and absurdity as a separate number.

A power may score low on usefulness but high on entertainment. Do not collapse the two scales into an unexplained overall verdict.

Put it into practice

Use two labeled rating scales and read their endpoints before voting. One person may find biscuit detection useful while another finds it absurd. Display both judgments rather than averaging away the very disagreement that makes the card interesting.

Give the rating a scenario

Usefulness is hard to rate without saying useful for what. Choose one fictional task before collecting numbers, such as preparing a tiny museum opening. A power that makes object labels rhyme may help the theme while slowing visitors who need a plain explanation. Ask each rater to consider the whole card, including its side effect and restriction. Otherwise players may be judging three different versions of the same ability.

Keep usefulness and absurdity on separate scales. A highly absurd power can also be genuinely helpful within the fictional task, and a dull restriction can make an impressive ability inconvenient. Explain the endpoints in ordinary language before voting: zero usefulness means it contributes nothing to this task, while ten means it fits the task extremely well under its stated rules. Those are your group's interpretations, not scientific measurements. Record a short reason next to a rating if players want to compare their thinking later. When numbers differ, ask which assumption caused the difference rather than forcing everyone toward an average they do not believe. For a final comparison, change the task and rate again. Seeing the order shift from museum opening to picnic hosting demonstrates the limits of the original score more clearly than declaring one superpower universally best or worst.

A few good questions

Can usefulness and absurdity be combined automatically?

Keep the scales labeled separately unless an explicit formula is announced. Different judgments are useful discussion, not a calculation error.

Plan your session

Take it to the game

Play now ↗

More original ideas · Game night guides

Find your next good question

Your games, your device

Players, answers, favorites, and history stay in this browser. Export a backup before clearing browser storage.

Select a backup to preview its record count.

Recovery copies

Restore and clear operations keep a pre-change copy in this browser. Download one before restoring it.